Why Performance Management Goes Wrong
[Replace with your take on why managers avoid performance conversations — discomfort, uncertainty, fear of retaliation claims — and what that avoidance costs.] Most performance problems don't start as performance problems. They start as small issues that a manager notices but doesn't address — until they become impossible to ignore. By then, the documentation gap is significant.
Step 1: Document Specifically and Promptly
[Replace with your guidance on what good documentation looks like — specific, factual, dated, behavior-focused rather than personality-focused.] Documentation is not about building a case against an employee. It's about creating an accurate record that protects everyone — including the employee — if a dispute arises later. Vague notes like "attitude issues" are almost useless. Specific, behavioral observations are what matter.
Step 2: Have the Conversation Early
[Replace with your framework for an initial performance conversation — how to open it, what to say, how to make it a two-way discussion, and how to document it.] The best performance conversations happen before the situation becomes serious. Early feedback — delivered clearly and respectfully — gives the employee a genuine opportunity to course-correct.
Step 3: Set Clear, Written Expectations
[Replace with guidance on written performance expectations — what they should include, how they differ from a PIP, and when each is appropriate.] After a performance conversation, expectations should be confirmed in writing. This doesn't have to be a formal PIP — sometimes a simple follow-up email summarizing what was discussed and agreed is sufficient.
Step 4: Know When to Escalate to HR
[Replace with your guidance on when a manager should stop handling a performance issue independently and loop in HR or outside support.] There are situations where a manager should not be handling performance issues alone — when protected characteristics are involved, when the employee has raised a complaint, or when termination is being considered.
The One Thing Most Managers Get Wrong
[Replace with your most important practical insight — the single thing that would most improve how managers handle performance in small businesses.] The most common mistake isn't saying the wrong thing. It's waiting too long to say anything at all.
Want Your Managers to Handle This Better?
ComplyBridgeHR's Manager Fundamentals Training gives your team leads the frameworks and confidence to manage people compliantly.
Learn About Manager Training →